Thursday, December 9, 2010

Cool Carla Vs.Hot Michelle....!

Since there is a meaningless sartorial debate raging..... here's my take on the American First Lady. As for Carla.... I hope and pray she and hubby Sarko do produce their 'Made-in-India' beta - the one they prayed for at the Ajmer durgah .

*******************


Forget her funny frocks (whatever happened to the famous Lady O style?), and focus on her funny lines (“Ask my husband tough questions,” she urged students in Mumbai – and they did!). Michelle Obama won the popularity stakes hands down even as Barack, the ‘Most Powerful Man on Earth’ (still?) attempted and failed the charm offensive. You know why? Michelle was herself, while the President was programmed. He may have one of the toughest jobs in the world, but hey – hers is not that easy either. If anything, it’s equally demanding and less acknowledged. Being First Lady is not what it used to be. The birdlike Mrs. Reagan had perfected the ‘the gaze’, Mrs. Clinton, the scowl, while nobody remembers what it was that Mrs. Bush contributed to her husband’s presidency. But here comes Michelle – a strapping, handsome woman with a Harvard law degree, who started her innings rather shakily with a couple of unorthodox remarks that shook the establishment and got the media on high alert. Perhaps the President’s minders advised her to back off and zip up, for after those early, unguarded provocative comments that were dubbed ‘racist’ ( sweet irony), the first Black American woman to occupy the White House has won admirers across the world for her warmth and spontaneity. In fact, her ratings are at an all time high, even as Barack struggles to deal with a major setback in Congress back home. His India visit couldn’t have been worse timed – for him and us. He picked mid-Diwali to visit. It’s a little like Manmohan Singh picking a X’Mas or Thanksgiving weekend to call on the Obamas and expecting the average Joe in Washington to hang around and welcome him. Well, Singh may be King in India, and the comparison isn’t too apt, but you get the drift. Michelle was expected to make up for her husband’s glumness and lack of charm, which she did in abundance. Now here’s the catch – she did not take the old route where all the First Ladies were required to do on state visits was look good and smile a lot ( yoo hoo Jackie O!). Michelle, in her own special way, demonstrated an important trait – she was convincingly her own woman, speaking her mind spontaneously and reaching out generously to one and all. Michelle won our hearts. Obama’s job was to win our minds. Between the two, it was clearly Michelle who emerged the real star.
It takes a great amount of intelligence for a woman in her position to underplay her own personality without it appearing fake. My guess is the Obamas are on to a good thing in their marriage. She has no ego issues, and neither does he when it comes to his wife. Unlike Hillary Clinton, who often came across a bit too strongly and appeared unattractively feisty, Michelle’s personality is appealingly non-threatening - to men and women. Kids, of course, adore her – she speaks their lingo and accesses their world effortlessly ( playing hop scotch in Mumbai didn’t look like a staged photo-op at all ) . Her smile reaches her eyes and when she listens to her husband, she does so attentively but not rapturously. This pleases the feminist in all of us.
Much has been written about her dress sense and how local fashionistas were disappointed that she picked frumpy ‘safe’ outfits in drab colours for her India trip while her myriad fans had hoped for brights and bling. I had visualized her in a vibrant rani pink saree with chunky accessories or something a little more exotic (would have happily settled for a peacock brooch!). But it was her extraordinary ability to connect in a sincere and transparent way that shone through. If her husband ( Mr. Teleprompter ) managed to salvage his rather lackluster Mumbai chapter when he addressed both Houses of parliament in Delhi and came up with a few sparklers, it was Michelle Obama who walked away with our genuine admiration. As she waved her final goodbye, I found myself singing an old Bollywood hit picturised on Zeenat Aman several moons ago…. “ Chura liya hai dil…”
Barack Obama – we love your missus.

11 comments:

gaurav said...

madam, the title says michelle v/s karla, but karla seems to appear nowhere in the picture...
instead you have compared the two obamas

so i guess appropriate title could have been
"barack v/s michelle

Radhika Gupta said...

shaking a leg with little children or playing hop scotch... highly unlikely and unexpected by america's first lady.. michelle truly won the hearts of the indians with her charm, wit and humility...

cmpershad said...

`I hope and pray she and hubby Sarko'

Hope she does not say `SARKO, DOOSRE KO AANE DO' :)

sonal said...

this is a grt entry, wish u had written something more about Carla, she is jst such a controversial figure!
Oflate your blog posts on the Radia scandal were a real good read, infact all your comments on Barkhagate and your veiled defence of her, were very balanced and mature. It heartens me when you comment on serious issues as it maddens me when ppl call you a gossip columnist.well done!

Orange Peppercorn said...

That's a good post and just that the title is misleading as it has little about the french first lady.Expecting a post for Mr & Mrs Sarkozy!

alokita said...

The visit was useful. Content was really very informative. From www.gifts2germany.com

Sameer said...

and don't forget Michelle made our fishermen community happy like anything !! I agree with you -- the timing of Obama's visit was poorly planned. Don't they think about these cultural details when they plan a trip. One of my friend is a Police Officer in Mumbai and he hated Obama's visit during Diwali time as he could not spend time with his family....anyway, good post...and yeah...what abt. Mrs. Sarko....write something about her as well, no !! You know, everything is spicy when we have famous "Shobhaa-chi FodaNi"...so do write abt. our french first lady as well :)

AKSHAY SINGH said...

ma'am ...EXCELLENT ! hit the nail on head ...as always .And i wonder why I admire you more n more every day :-D

a little request ...Maybe it's a bit too much to ask...i dearly want to know your views on how gays are treated .
you wrote a couple of articles when sec.377 was abolished but they were about the 'acceptance' part of it .
A little about how you perceive gay people ...you point of view ( it has been given in bits and pieces but if it does not take up much of your time ...whenever you are free...maybe an article upon it )
THREE CHEERS ! :-D

Shalet Jimmy said...

True...Michelle Obama is somebody who can always look up to.

I thought I could read more about Carla Bruni...

Latha said...

Hey Shobhaa, what's this - a small conversation about you in radia tapes ? Copy & paste the fol: link & play the button in the box to listen to it.
http://www.outlookindia.com/article.aspx?268359

Siva Cool said...

A truly motivational and life changing book
This book is really a good book which shows us right path. but i read
one more book named "ONE BOOK FOR LIFE SUCCESS" which is truly
motivational and life changing . .The writer has described in Plain English with lot of examples which is easy to understand...For More
Please watch the videohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=biORjS8ngv0